Nexus Europa

NAZA Documentary Controversy: Why Israel Threatens to Revoke Filmmakers’ Citizenship

Elise Aranda
Posted September 15, 2026 · 4 views
Follow
Share
NAZA Documentary Controversy: Why Israel Threatens to Revoke Filmmakers’ Citizenship
Editorial Collage

After winning at the Venice Film Festival, the Gaza war documentary NAZA faces severe backlash from Netanyahu’s government, triggering threats of treason charges and legal probes over allegations of AI targeting and civilian casualties.

The last of these measures is still only a request for an investigation. It has not resulted in the loss of citizenship. But it puts an extraordinary question on the table: can a government treat the work of its own journalists and filmmakers as a matter of national loyalty during an ongoing war?

The citizenship threat is not as simple as it sounds

Zohar cannot simply revoke the directors' citizenship by ministerial order.

Israeli law provides for citizenship revocation in exceptional circumstances, including a breach of loyalty or assistance to an enemy during wartime. The procedure involves several stages. The Interior Ministry would have to initiate the process, state prosecutors would have to provide legal scrutiny, and the matter would ultimately require judicial determination by the Supreme Court.

That makes the government's move more political than immediately punitive. The authorities are being asked to find out whether the legal machinery exists to pursue the filmmakers in the first place.

Still, the choice of citizenship as the potential punishment is significant.

Citizenship is not normally an instrument for settling disputes over journalism. Raising its possible removal in response to an investigative documentary pushes the argument into a much more fundamental area: who remains inside the political community when the state is at war?

Zohar has asked authorities to examine how the directors obtained their material, whether they assisted the enemy and whether there are legal grounds for removing their nationality. Netanyahu's public attack gave the issue an even broader political frame, portraying the film as part of anti-Semitic incitement and accusing it of depicting the IDF as a criminal organisation.

The military response is following a separate track.

Zamir has described the documentary's allegations as “blood libels” and instructed the Military Advocate General to identify the sources and consider possible legal action. For the people who supplied the interviews, that may be the most immediate danger.

The film relies on 24 current and former military and intelligence personnel. Their identities were digitally anonymised. The military investigation is now intended, among other things, to establish who they are.

NAZA Documentary Controversy: Why Israel Threatens to Revoke Filmmakers’ Citizenship
NAZA directors Rachel Szor, left, and Yuval Abraham with the special jury award. Photograph: Yara Nardi/Reuters

The allegations concern the machinery of war

This is what makes NAZA more difficult for the government to dismiss as simply another political film.

The documentary is based on interviews with people who say they worked inside the Israeli military and intelligence system. Their accounts describe an increasingly automated approach to target selection in Gaza.

The film says AI-based systems were used to evaluate possible targets. It also describes mass mobile-phone tracking and digital surveillance of Gaza's population, as well as models that assigned numerical scores to people suspected of links to Hamas.

The most serious allegation concerns civilian casualties.

According to the sources interviewed for the documentary, military commanders could approve strikes on residential buildings even when they knew civilians, including children, would die. The decision, they say, could depend on whether the expected casualties fell within pre-established limits.

That is a very different proposition from saying that civilians were killed despite efforts to avoid them. It raises the possibility that anticipated civilian deaths were built into the target-selection process itself.

The title of the documentary comes from an Israeli military acronym for expected “collateral casualties”. It is a deliberately technical term for something that is anything but technical once the numbers represent children and families.

The wider implications are obvious enough without assuming that every allegation in the film has been independently established. Modern military operations increasingly depend on software, large datasets and automated systems. The question raised by NAZA is where responsibility sits when those systems help decide whether a strike goes ahead.

An algorithm does not establish its own rules.

Someone sets the criteria. Someone decides what data matters. Someone establishes how much anticipated civilian harm is considered acceptable. And someone ultimately authorises the operation.

Those are the questions that could prove harder to contain than the film itself.

One investigation does not answer the other

The Military Advocate General's inquiry is concerned with the people who may have disclosed military or intelligence information. Under military law, the office deals with service personnel, operational security and classified information.

That gives the investigation a clear legal basis for examining leaks.

It does not, by itself, establish whether the practices described by the anonymous sources were lawful.

Those are separate questions, and keeping them separate will matter if the allegations are examined outside Israel. The documentary contains testimony about targeting procedures, surveillance and casualty thresholds, while the Gaza health authorities report more than 73,700 deaths during the conflict, the majority identified as civilians.

The material could therefore attract interest from international legal and human rights investigators. Whether it would eventually be usable as evidence would depend on verification and the legal standards applied to it. Nothing in the present case establishes that an international judicial body has already accepted the documentary's testimony as evidence.

There is another problem for the sources themselves.

Their anonymity protects them only as long as their identities remain undiscovered. Zamir's order to identify the military and intelligence personnel behind the disclosures puts that protection under direct pressure.

For investigative journalism, this is potentially more consequential than the fate of the two filmmakers. If serving personnel believe that speaking anonymously about suspected wrongdoing can lead to a military investigation, the supply of information to journalists is likely to become harder.

The chilling effect does not require a conviction.

The threat can be enough.

Europe is watching a dispute that is becoming harder to contain

The setting of the controversy is significant. NAZA was the sole documentary in the official competition at Venice, and the reception there has given the film a much larger audience than it would have had as a domestic investigation.

Abraham and Szor also come to the controversy with an established record. Their previous film, No Other Land, documented Israeli settlement expansion and displacement in the West Bank and won an Academy Award.

Their new documentary moves inside the system.

That shift is one reason the political response has been so intense. The film does not only document the effects of the Gaza war. Through the testimony of people who say they worked within the military and intelligence apparatus, it makes claims about how decisions leading to those effects were made.

European governments cannot easily separate that argument from the broader debate already taking place around Israel's conduct of the war.

European media organisations have treated the citizenship threat as a political initiative rather than a completed legal measure, stressing the judicial and statutory barriers involved. Inside Israel, meanwhile, the reaction has not been confined to government supporters. About 700 people from the country's film industry have signed a petition defending the directors and warning against state retaliation.

That leaves Israel's European relationships facing another layer of political pressure.

The issue is not simply whether European governments agree with NAZA. They also have to deal with a dispute over whether criticism of a state's military during wartime can be treated as disloyalty to the state itself.

For Netanyahu's government, linking the film to anti-Semitism offers a potent political message. It places the documentary within a wider narrative of Israel being attacked internationally and allows criticism of military conduct to be presented as part of that attack.

For critics of the government, the same argument crosses an important line: disagreement over military policy becomes a question of loyalty.

That distinction will matter long after the Venice award is forgotten.

The immediate legal barriers mean that Abraham and Szor are not about to lose their citizenship simply because a minister has requested an investigation. But the government has already demonstrated that citizenship, military secrecy and accusations of treason can be brought into the same political dispute.

And once that happens, the question is no longer confined to one film. It becomes a question for the next soldier who considers speaking to a journalist, the next reporter investigating the military, and the next government deciding whether wartime security is a reason to protect state institutions from scrutiny - or a reason to scrutinise them more closely.

Read also:

Sources: Aljazeera, Euronews, The Arab Weekly, AP

Share