Nexus Europa

UN Endorsement of Equal Earth Projection Sparks Geopolitical Feud Over Crimea and Kuril Islands

Elise Aranda
Posted September 11, 2026 · 8 views
Follow
Share
UN Endorsement of Equal Earth Projection Sparks Geopolitical Feud Over Crimea and Kuril Islands
Editorial Collage

The UN General Assembly’s decision to endorse the Equal Earth projection was supposed to correct a long-standing distortion in how the planet is represented. Instead, within days, the vote had opened disputes over Crimea, the Kuril Islands and Kashmir - exposing a problem far more consequential than cartographic design. Once a map becomes an institutional standard, the question is no longer simply how accurately it represents geography, but whose version of sovereignty it appears to recognise.

On September 4, the General Assembly backed a Togo-initiated resolution recommending wider use of equal-area projections, specifically the Equal Earth projection. The vote was overwhelming: 164 countries supported it, the United States opposed it and six countries abstained, including Ukraine and Lithuania.

Japan voted in favour. Six days later, Tokyo formally protested the way the Equal Earth map depicts the Southern Kuril Islands, which Japan calls the Northern Territories. The islands are shown in the same colour as Russia and labelled with Russian place names.

That sequence captures the central contradiction of the entire exercise. Governments can agree that the world should be mapped more fairly while disagreeing profoundly over what, exactly, the map should say about the world.

The problem with Mercator was never just political

The case for moving away from Mercator is straightforward.

Created by Gerardus Mercator in 1569, the projection was designed primarily for navigation. It preserves angles and lines of constant bearing, making it extremely useful for sailors. But the price of that functionality is severe distortion of land areas, particularly towards the poles.

The visual consequence has shaped generations of people's mental geography. Greenland can appear comparable in size to Africa, even though Africa covers about 30.3 mn square kilometres and Greenland about 2.16 mn.

Equal Earth, developed in 2018 by Bojan Šavrič, Tom Patterson and Bernhard Jenny, takes a different approach. It is an equal-area pseudocylindrical projection designed to preserve the relative size of land masses while maintaining continent shapes that remain visually familiar. It was intended for thematic maps, statistics, and education rather than navigation.

UN Endorsement of Equal Earth Projection Sparks Geopolitical Feud Over Crimea and Kuril Islands
The new Equal Earth world map more accurately reflects the real areas of the continents.

Togo's initiative therefore had a clear intellectual and political rationale. A map that gives a more accurate visual representation of the relative size of continents also challenges a centuries-old hierarchy in which Africa and other tropical regions have routinely appeared smaller than they are.

The problem began when the projection stopped being merely a mathematical solution.

The moment an international institution endorses a particular map, the colours, labels and borders placed on it acquire political meaning.

Crimea exposes the fault line

For Ukraine, that meaning was enough to justify staying outside the consensus.

Kyiv abstained from the September 4 vote because of how temporarily occupied territories were represented on the Equal Earth website and its promotional material. In particular, Crimea was shown with distinct shading from the rest of Ukraine, although not in the same colour as Russia.

Ukraine's Permanent Mission to the UN and MP Kira Rudyk argued that this treatment conflicts with the principle of Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity. Ukrainian representatives spent two days negotiating before the vote in an attempt to secure wording that would address the issue. No compromise was reached.

Lithuania cited the same cartographic treatment of Crimea when explaining its abstention.

The objection is not simply aesthetic. In 2014, the UN General Assembly adopted Resolution 68/262, affirming Ukraine's territorial integrity and calling on states and international agencies not to recognise any alteration of Crimea's status.

That creates a difficult distinction for cartographers. A map can acknowledge who physically controls a territory without formally recognising that control as lawful. But visual distinctions can blur the line between those two things, particularly when they appear on material associated with an international standard.

A different colour may be intended as a neutral cartographic device. To a government defending a territorial claim, it can look like a political statement.

Japan's yes vote, and its protest

Japan's position reveals another dimension of the problem.

Tokyo supported the UN resolution itself because the underlying principle - moving towards a more accurate representation of land area — was not the issue. The dispute concerned the specific implementation of the Equal Earth map.

On September 10, Japanese government representative Minoru Kihara announced Tokyo's diplomatic protest. Japan objected to Iturup, Kunashir, Shikotan and the Habomai group being coloured as part of Russia and identified using Russian place names.

UN Endorsement of Equal Earth Projection Sparks Geopolitical Feud Over Crimea and Kuril Islands
The disputed islands are located in an archipelago between Russia and Japan. (ABC NEWS)

The dispute over these islands dates to the end of the Second World War, when Soviet forces occupied them. Japan regards them as its Northern Territories, and the unresolved dispute has prevented the two countries from signing a formal peace treaty ending the war.

So Japan could simultaneously support a cartographic reform and reject one particular territorial representation produced under that reform. There is no contradiction once the two questions are separated.

The resolution concerned the projection. The map concerned sovereignty.

That distinction, however, is precisely what makes the episode politically important.

One map for Japan, another for everyone else

Tom Patterson, one of the creators of Equal Earth, offered a compromise that may prove more significant than the original dispute.

Following Japan's protest, Patterson said a revised Japanese-language version would be produced, while the global English-language version would remain unchanged.

His reasoning rests on a distinction between legal claims and physical control. As a cartographer, Patterson argued, his role is to represent de facto control, even where he regards the underlying geopolitical reality as unacceptable.

That produces a practical solution for Japan without altering the global map.

It also creates an uncomfortable precedent.

UN Endorsement of Equal Earth Projection Sparks Geopolitical Feud Over Crimea and Kuril Islands
Japan says the disputed Kuril islands are marked in the same colour as Russia. (Equal Earth/Tom Patterson)

If a cartographic representation can be modified for one national-language edition while remaining unchanged in the international version, then the map is no longer operating according to a single universal standard. Instead, it becomes layered: one version for a government whose territorial claim is affected, another for the wider international audience.

That may be defensible as a way of avoiding diplomatic escalation. But it raises a harder question for future maps: when does accommodating national sensitivities become a fragmentation of international standards?

The issue becomes particularly acute in territories where military control and legal sovereignty diverge.

If physical control is the primary criterion, Russia's control of Crimea or the Southern Kurils can become the basis for visual representation. If international legal status is the criterion, the map must preserve claims that are not reflected on the ground. If the answer is to show both, the cartographer needs conventions precise enough to distinguish occupation, dispute, administration and sovereignty without making the map unreadable.

There is no purely technical solution to that problem.

The UN already has rules for disputed territory

The difficulty is not that international organisations have never dealt with contested borders.

UN cartographic practice includes conventions designed to avoid presenting disputed boundaries as settled facts. In Jammu and Kashmir, for example, the Line of Control is traditionally shown as a dashed line accompanied by a disclaimer that its final status has not been determined.

India nevertheless raised concerns during the Equal Earth debate, supporting the equal-area principle while flagging the treatment of Kashmir, Arunachal Pradesh and Aksai Chin. New Delhi pointed to differences between established UN conventions and imagery associated with the map.

The broader problem is that traditional diplomatic cartography was designed around specific disputes and established conventions. Digital maps and open-source cartographic projects operate at a different scale. A single visual resource can circulate globally, be translated into multiple languages and be incorporated into educational, statistical and institutional material.

Every design choice travels with it.

The United States, meanwhile, cast the only vote against the resolution, citing broader objections to its text and approach rather than the territorial questions that concerned Ukraine, Japan or India. The overwhelming vote therefore should not be mistaken for a universal agreement on what the resulting maps ought to look like.

The disagreement was simply distributed differently.

When representation becomes recognition

The deeper shift is from diplomacy over territory to diplomacy over representation.

For decades, territorial disputes have been fought through treaties, military deployments, diplomatic notes and international resolutions. Increasingly, they are also fought through the systems that describe the world: maps, databases, digital platforms and technical standards.

That gives seemingly neutral decisions a new strategic significance.

A border is no longer only a line negotiated between states. It can be a colour on a map. Sovereignty can be implied by a place name. Occupation can acquire an appearance of permanence simply because a digital reference tool depicts the territory according to who controls it.

Patterson's decision makes the dilemma unusually clear. The global English-language map will continue to represent de facto control, while Japan receives a revised national-language version. The approach avoids forcing a single answer onto an unresolved dispute.

But it leaves the fundamental question untouched: when an international audience sees a territory represented as belonging to the state that physically controls it, is the map merely describing reality - or helping to normalise it?

That is the problem the UN's cartographic reform has unexpectedly placed on the diplomatic table. The geometry of the map may be scientific. The politics begin at its borders.

Read also:

  • On September 4, the UN General Assembly voted 164–1 to adopt Resolution A/80/L.104, encouraging a shift from the centuries-old Mercator projection to the equal-area Equal Earth map. While the decision aims to correct historical visual distortions of the Global South, it immediately turned cartography into a geopolitical battleground. With the United States standing alone in opposition, France pledging full adoption, and Ukraine abstaining over Russian-shaded depictions of Crimea, the non-binding vote exposes deep fault lines between post-colonial representation, Western consensus, and national sovereignty.

Sources: ABC Kyiv Post The Week

Share