Nexus Europa

Italy’s New Antisemitism Law Raises Concerns Over Freedom of Expression

Jian Oren
Posted November 18, 2026 · 3 views
Follow
Share
Italy’s New Antisemitism Law Raises Concerns Over Freedom of Expression
Editorial Collage

Italy has adopted legislation formally incorporating the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism into domestic law, triggering concerns that measures intended to combat anti-Jewish hatred could also restrict criticism of Israel and pro-Palestinian activism. The decision has exposed tensions between anti-discrimination policies, freedom of expression and the political direction of Giorgia Meloni’s government.

Italy’s parliament has given final approval to legislation introducing the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism into national law, prompting criticism from human rights organisations and opposition parties. The Chamber of Deputies approved the measure on 17 November by 147 votes to 93, with five lawmakers abstaining. The legislation, titled Measures for Countering Antisemitism and for the Adoption of the Working Definition of Antisemitism, had previously passed the Senate on 2 March 2026.

The law establishes the IHRA definition, adopted in 2016, as the reference framework for Italian institutions when identifying and addressing antisemitism. It also incorporates the definition's accompanying examples, which include denying Jewish people the right to self-determination, comparing contemporary Israeli policies with those of Nazi Germany and holding Jewish communities collectively responsible for the actions of the Israeli government.

Although the legislation does not introduce new criminal offences or financial penalties, its formal adoption into domestic law gives the definition a more prominent role in shaping public policies and institutional responses. Its provisions cover measures involving education, universities, online platforms and initiatives aimed at monitoring and preventing antisemitism.

Amnesty Warns of a Chilling Effect on Political Debate

Amnesty International has strongly criticised the legislation, describing its adoption as a serious setback for freedom of expression. The organisation argues that the IHRA definition, particularly its illustrative examples, does not sufficiently distinguish between antisemitic hatred and legitimate political criticism of the Israeli state and its policies.

According to Amnesty, the law could create conditions in which criticism of Israel's occupation, its treatment of Palestinians and its military operations in Gaza is interpreted as antisemitic. This could encourage self-censorship among journalists, academics, civil society organisations and activists concerned about the potential consequences of expressing political positions.

The organisation also warns that applying the definition across educational institutions, social media platforms and other public spaces could affect the ability to organise demonstrations, conduct academic research and engage in political debate. While the legislation does not establish new criminal sanctions, Amnesty argues that its institutional application could still have a restrictive effect on public discourse.

The controversy centres partly on the relationship between the IHRA definition and its accompanying examples. Although the definition itself describes antisemitism as a particular perception of Jewish people that may be expressed as hatred, some of its examples refer directly to positions concerning Israel and Zionism. Critics argue that incorporating these examples into national legislation risks blurring the distinction between hostility towards Jewish people and opposition to the policies of a particular state.

Political Divisions and an Alternative Definition

The legislation has also exposed divisions within Italy's political opposition. Left-wing parties, including the Five Star Movement and the Green-Left Alliance, opposed the measure, arguing that it could undermine the rights of those expressing solidarity with Palestinians. Angelo Bonelli, co-leader of the Green-Left Alliance, described the legislation as an attempt to restrict criticism of the Israeli government.

Opposition lawmakers had proposed replacing the IHRA framework with the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism, developed in 2021 by scholars specialising in antisemitism, Jewish studies and Holocaust research. Unlike the IHRA framework, the declaration places greater emphasis on distinguishing antisemitism from criticism of Israel, including opposition to Zionism, support for boycotts and evidence-based criticism of Israeli government policies.

However, the proposed amendments were rejected, and the final legislation retained the IHRA definition and its accompanying indicators. The vote also revealed disagreements within the centre-left Democratic Party, with some lawmakers abstaining rather than following the party leadership's position.

The government of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has rejected accusations that the legislation threatens freedom of expression. Supporters argue that criticism of Israeli government policies remains legitimate and that the measure does not prohibit political debate. They also point to the need for stronger institutional responses to rising antisemitism, particularly following the increase in reported incidents across Europe since the Hamas-led attacks on Israel on 7 October 2023 and the subsequent war in Gaza.

Rising Antisemitism Complicates the Debate

The legislation comes amid growing concerns about antisemitic incidents in Italy. The country's Antisemitism Observatory recorded 963 incidents in 2025, almost four times the number reported in 2022. Reports of physical aggression against Jewish people have also increased, with 18 incidents involving people being pushed, spat at or slapped recorded in 2025 and another 10 reported during the first half of 2026.

These figures have strengthened arguments among supporters of the legislation that existing measures are insufficient to address the problem. Italy's Jewish community organisations have also welcomed the adoption of a formal framework, viewing it as an important step towards strengthening institutional recognition of antisemitism and protecting Jewish communities.

Nevertheless, the central question remains whether the new framework can be implemented without undermining other fundamental rights. Combating antisemitism requires effective measures against discrimination, intimidation and violence, but these objectives do not necessarily require treating criticism of state policies as a form of prejudice.

Implications for European Democracies

Italy's decision adds another dimension to an ongoing European debate over how governments should define and address antisemitism while safeguarding freedom of expression. Several European countries and institutions already use the IHRA definition as a policy reference, but its legal status and practical application differ considerably. Italy's decision to incorporate the framework into national legislation represents a more consequential step, potentially influencing future discussions about the relationship between anti-discrimination policy and political speech.

The case also raises questions about the responsibilities of governments when adopting international definitions as instruments of domestic policy. A framework initially designed to help identify antisemitism can acquire a different significance when embedded in legislation and applied by public institutions. The consequences will therefore depend not only on the wording of the law but also on how authorities interpret its provisions in practice.

For Meloni's government, the legislation reinforces its political positioning on Israel and the fight against antisemitism, while exposing it to criticism over the potential consequences for civil liberties. It also creates a test for Italy's institutions, which will need to demonstrate that measures against antisemitism can be implemented without restricting legitimate political opposition or public scrutiny.

The broader European challenge is to ensure that the protection of Jewish communities and the preservation of democratic freedoms remain mutually reinforcing objectives. If the Italian framework is applied too broadly, it could intensify existing divisions over the war in Gaza and the limits of political expression. Its implementation will consequently be closely watched by human rights organisations, academic institutions and governments across Europe.

Sources: Amnesty International, Italian Senate

Share
Italy’s New Antisemitism Law Raises Concerns Over Freedom of Expression — Nexus Europa